Wednesday, March 2, 2011

What phone to buy Samsung Glaxy Mini(Pop), Fit or Ace?

This is a mail i wrote to my friend who asked me which one to buy of the three mentioned in the subject. Just posting it here as per his suggestion:

Glaxy ace (S5830) is more in price than than Pop (S5570 aka Mini) and Fit (S5670) so it will have more features and
better look and feel. Nevertheless other phones also has similar features. If u have a stringent budget, I would
suggest u personally see a demo and buy it. In case you are going to buy other than Ace. Some of my friends suggested Wave II check that also.

One of the key thing is look and feel. I liked Ace beacuse it was looking like i-phone to be honest. Check these
links for look and feel:

Another thing is touch sensitivity ( for this i recommend u c a demo), anyway u will notice the look and feel when u see a demo. Ace sensitivity is good.
- For your knowlege there are 2 types of touch screen: Resistive (depends on pressure) and Capacitive (depends on the conductive properties of touching material)
- I-phone and most touch senstive (Glaxy) uses capacitive. In low end smart phones Corby series uses capcitive touch screen.
- Nokia (many models I have seen) and low priced phones uses resistive that's not so sensitive.
- Normally resistive comes with Stylus and suited for finger touch.

Screen size is also very important for smart when (to read and edit document)
Screen size is comaprtive to price Ace has 3.5", Mini has 3.15" and Fit 3.31". Ace screen size is same as i-phone screen size for u to imagine the screen size.
The resolution is also better in Ace (which determines the clarity of display): Ace: 320x480 pixels and Fit: 240x320.

OS also plays a role in tocuch screen and speed:
- All 3 phones has android 2.2 Froyo.

Processer speed (Now a days became important for mobile also, as it does multitasking):
- Pop(Mini): 600Mhz
- Fit: 600Mhz
- Ace: 800Mhz (here ace is more powerful)
Even the flagship model Galaxy S has 1GHz processor only.

Camera (another key feature in a smart phone):
Pop: 3MP (No Flash)
Fit: 5MP (No Flash) - I see no flash as big drawback for 5MP camera.
Ace: 5MP (with Flash)

Batterry: Both Ace and Fit has the same power battery (1350 mAh) where as Mini(Pop) has 1200mAh, which is expected. I feel if Ace is powered with 1500mAh it will much better for battery backup, than it will increase the price. This is the battery used in Galaxy S which cost nealy 28K.
As one of the drawbacks i see we need to charge these smart phones daily comapred to normal phone which will come for 3 days. This is because of the display and the data featues it uses synch up with mail maps etc in background. There are ways to save power which u can use, reduce the display brightness and remove autosync up for mails. Other than these i dont see any drawback.

Audio, Office, Chat, Social and Mail applications are similar in all these 3 phones.

Price (most important thing): this is as on 1-Mar-2011
Model: Price (with VAT)
Pop: 8,846 (9,200)
Fit: 10, 144 (10,550)
Ace: 14,615(15,200) - I got it for 15,100/- (The actual price has decreased few 100's in weeks time. When i was

checking with tax it was 15,600/-).

If you are a techie guy then better go for Android phone, tight integration with Google service is Amazing!! you need to experience to feel it. I will compare with optimus later and provide my comments. I have not recommended because I am liitle biased towards Ace and I feel it more depends on what u need. So only I have listed the Key difference and advatages. I will check with my collgue also for some inputs, he only suggested me Ace so his inputs are worth it.

Reference:
1. Check "GSM arena" for specifications and user comments, click on the image in specs to see full sized image.
2. "Tech tree" review also help, in choosing in a price range check that, i will send u the link later.
3. I use univercell website to check the price, prices displayed are without Tax, Univercell also gives EMI option if ur buying online.

4 comments:

  1. Comment by my collegue:
    Hi Saravanan,

    You have already put down on the necessary points. Pop or Fit are lower end of Andriod phones and may not have the same experience (sensitivity, smoothness etc) as that of ACE.

    If budget permits, go for ACE.

    If the budget does not permit, I would probably recommend to go for FIT as it has a better battery, camera, slightly bigger screen and slightly better resolution (based on the data from gsmarena). I would give more importance to Battery as smartphones need lot of power. I suppose you are charging your phone daily !!


    Regards,
    Ram

    ReplyDelete
  2. My comment on Optimus One:
    Anbu, LG Optimus One P500 is also good. one advantage I see is it has more powerful battery (1500mAh) compared to Ace anf Fit (1350mAh) which means can come for few more hours.

    However the camera is only 3.15MP. Optimums is good compared fit, but when compared with Ace looks better. There is good review for Optimus, in fact Sara told 2 of his colleagues are having it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Comment by my friend Anbu:
    Hi AS,

    Thanks. I think you should put this analysis in your blog. Looks good.

    regards,
    Anbu

    ReplyDelete
  4. I heard from a mobile shop sales person, that "Galaxy S" has been released with TFT screen now which costs around 20K (19.something). This is a very good option if u like Galaxy S with Super AMOLED display which costs around 30K (to be more accurate its around 28K).

    ReplyDelete